Best MIDI Keyboards: An In-Dept Look At the Market

Best MIDI keyboards

As our website name implies, we focus mainly on pianos, specifically the electronic variants that serve as viable learning and practice tools for all skill levels.

So far, our site has focused discussion on digital pianos and keyboards for the budget-conscious buyer. Our most recent article challenged us to pick out a beginner’s training tool for under $150, which was no small feat.

MIDI Keyboard icon

One of the options we offered was a combination of a MIDI Keyboard alongside a VST plugin (the Nektar GX61 and XLN Audio’s Addictive Keys). This was an interesting take on things, as we’ve yet to cover MIDI keyboards and controllers.

We’ve covered our favorite acoustic piano VST plugins, courtesy of Samantha Van der Sluis. These plugins are ideal companions to the MIDI keyboards we’ll cover in this article.

Now, let’s discover MIDI keyboards in detail. There’s a lot to consider, especially since our prior knowledge about companies like Yamaha, Roland, and other prolific digital piano manufacturers don’t apply.

To start things off, we’ll begin by providing a general introduction to MIDI controllers, which will be helpful for newcomers or people who are merely curious.

We then go through our selection criteria and specific factors that might change your own decisions, before proceeding with our list of top picks.

To streamline things and to ensure you’re making informed decisions, we’ll offer our personal favorites based on use cases, while also providing some alternatives that might be worth considering.

If you’re not new to the market of MIDI keyboards and know exactly what you’re looking for, feel free to skip the following sections and jump to the reviews of the Best MIDI Keyboards on the market.

An Introduction to MIDI Controllers

MIDI is an acronym for Musical Instrument Digital Interface, and it’s the current technical standard protocol for signal transfer in digital musical instruments.

The most general form of MIDI data is note data, whereby each note we play on the keybed has specific properties.

MIDI definition

For example, if I play middle C for a few seconds before letting go, the sound chip receives a C3 trigger, velocity/sensitivity data, the length of the note, whether or not the sustain pedal is pressed, and potentially more information depending on what sensor architecture the keybed uses.

There’s a lot of interesting online information about MIDI, and there’s even a 2.0 revision ‘coming soon’ that promises a lot. I enjoy reading about it all, but let’s be frank, we’re musicians first and engineers second, so I’ll cut to the chase.

MIDI piano roll DAW

MIDI as the industry standard is great because it allows instruments from different manufacturers to communicate with each other.

For example, if I had the Roland FP-90 (which we’ve reviewed previously), and I purchased the Analog Four MKII synthesizer (which does not have keys), I could link them together with a standard 5-pin MIDI connector.

Once connected, any notes I play on the FP-90 would trigger sounds on the Analog Four MKII seamlessly.

That’s not the only possible combination. Nearly all instruments can communicate this way. If the goal was to trigger the Analog Four MKII, we could use anything from the cheap Casio CT-S300 to the gargantuan Yamaha AvantGrands.

MIDI keyboard performance

This isn’t even limited to synthesizers. If you were inclined, you could control a Korg Grandstage (a stage piano we like) with a Nord Piano 4, a Nord Stage with a Korg D1. You could even link two Roland FP-90s.

Of course, whether you need any of this is another question, but the option exists.

VST Musical Instruments

The more modern solution is to utilize VST software plugins, which run on any computer while controlled by MIDI.

This is a common occurrence, and we’ll test all our choices here using VST software on a laptop connected by USB.

Sure, we might need to be smart with connectors, but the essential takeaway is that nearly everything can communicate via MIDI. MIDI controllers adopt this approach in another way, too.

All the previous options we brought up assume you have a key-based instrument by your side, but if you’re just going to be triggering sounds off another source, you don’t exactly need built-in sounds, right?

Hence, MIDI controllers are purely signal-sending devices that don’t generate their own sounds. While this is an oversimplification, that’s the essence of MIDI.

MIDI controllers often offer bonuses. MIDI is more than just note and pedal data. MIDI information also exists as Continuous Controllers (CC) and Program Changes (PC).

These are mostly used when you turn knobs or hit buttons on your instrument, nothing too exciting.

However, it is particularly important on MIDI controllers, as you’ll never know what you’ll end up controlling. Controlling piano software is straightforward, but what if you want some drawbars for an organ module or filter knobs for a synthesizer?

MIDI Controllers or MIDI Keyboards?

You may have noticed that we called them MIDI controllers, not MIDI keyboards. No one said keys were a must.

One of the most successful early MIDI controllers was the AKAI MPK-series, which had keys, but was praised for having well-built buttons, knobs, faders, and so-on. It also came with AKAI’s iconic drum pads.

Let’s talk about the drum pads first. AKAI was famous for making the classic MPC music production center, a compact instrument based around pad-based control.

This was used by early hip-hop producers such as Dr. Dre, J. Dilla, and more. Even today, artists like Kanye West still swear by the workflow.

Pads were never taken seriously as a substitute for keys, but that didn’t stop companies like Ableton and Native Instruments from creating the “pad only” Ableton Push and Native Instruments Maschine.

These are impressive MIDI controllers and inventive new instruments. However, we won’t be covering them in this article, as they’re too far off from actual key-based piano for our skills to be transferrable.

There are also unique controllers such as the AKAI Midimix and the Novation Launch Control. These were MIDI controllers that omitted the keys entirely and hit the mark for audiences who wanted workflow enhancers instead of keyboards with extras.

For the purposes of this article, we’ll focus on MIDI keyboards and use the terms interchangeably.

Who Are MIDI Controllers For?

MIDI controllers were mainly designed for home-based music producers using digital audio workstations (DAW). This means the most common use for modern MIDI controllers is connecting to a computer, either desktop or laptop.

This is further evidenced by the rise of USB MIDI, as opposed to the classic 5-pin MIDI connection.

MIDI keyboard studio setup

However, being ‘for producers only’ is not a hard-set rule. More and more MIDI controllers are geared towards performers and keyboardists. This rise was dubbed ‘controllerism’ by DJ and live performer Moldover back in 2005.

This attempted to take the best parts of MIDI and merge them with more traditionalist live performance styles. This involved sample triggering via pads, gradual morphing changes using knobs, and live volume mixing with faders.

If all this sounds familiar, that’s because it’s a paradigm adopted by most modern stage pianos, such as the Roland RD-2000 which we praised for offering a lot of hands-on control.

We’ve always advocated for using stage pianos in live performances, but I’d argue that MIDI controllers deserve just as much attention.

Bands are incorporating laptops and MIDI controllers more and more into their live sets (even guitarists and drummers!). Having the flexibility of software with hands-on physical control is quite liberating.

With performance-oriented DAWs like Ableton Live becoming more commonplace, there is no reason to avoid dabbling in the possibilities.

Software is getting increasingly powerful, with the biggest hurdle of latency (or what we commonly call lag) being less and less relevant with modern hardware.

I’d say the traditional answer of MIDI keyboards being strictly for producers is outdated. Any performer can benefit from using performance software and MIDI controllers.

Are MIDI Keyboards a Valid Replacement to Digital Pianos?

MIDI keyboard vs Digital Piano

MIDI keyboards are valid practice tools for budding pianists and keyboardists. While the setup may turn some away, the cheaper price is a bargain. We won’t get detailed here, but you can make it work.

Our stance remains, if you want to learn the piano specifically, you need a good set of realistic keys and sounds. MIDI keyboards aren’t suited for this goal.

So, if your goal is to become a pianist, I’d suggest going with some of the selections from our other lists. Weighted MIDI keyboards exist (as we’ll cover below), but they’re expensive and don’t offer any sounds.

Our Selection Criteria

Unlike our usual lists, we’ll be a bit more lenient with our choices. There won’t be the typical 88 weighted key rule here, because as we just discussed, we aren’t looking for the best piano replacement.

Shopping for MIDI controller

For MIDI keyboards and controllers, we are looking for:

  • Good build quality
  • Nice-feeling keys (which means it must have keys)
  • Pitch-bend and modwheel
  • Velocity/pressure sensitivity

That’s a short list due to the important factors you need to consider. At the least, this ensures that any recommendation we make will feel well-built and playable, and you won’t regret your purchase.

However, you’ll need to make a few decisions yourself. Some MIDI controller models come in different keybed sizes, ranging from a miniature 25-keys to the full piano-sized 88, and the models are essentially the same apart from the number of keys.

MIDI keyboard studio

Hence, you’ll need to judge the following on your own merits:

1) Number of Keys: More keys mean a higher price and more bulk, which might be unnecessary if you’re not playing classical pieces.

We find that 49 keys are good enough for synthesizer-focused players, whereas 61 keys are a good amount for keyboardists who need organ-style keys.

2) Key Type: Synth-action keys are most common, but semi-weighted and weighted options exist as well. You’re probably familiar enough with synth-action and weighted piano-style keys.

Semi-weighted keys are quite rare in the realm of digital pianos (though we did see them on the 73-key Nord Stage), but they strike a balance between versatility and responsiveness.

Synth unweighted key action

3) Number of Controls: Knobs and buttons are good to have and easy to assign software functions with MIDI Learn. However, most of us don’t need a full digital mixing board. If we did, we’d be buying something else. Knowing what you need is key.

If you’re looking at the Nektar GX49 for instance, but don’t need the controls, you can get the same keybed on the stripped-down Nektar SE49.

4) Aftertouch: Typical pressure sensitivity tracks the pressure on the down press, but aftertouch continues to detect how hard you’re pushing down until you let go.

Assigning this to an effect such as rotary speaker speed for organs is great for adding extra layers of expressivity to your performances.

5) 5-Pin MIDI Support: MIDI controllers are sometimes marketed as “USB only,” which means the manufacturers don’t offer MIDI connections. This isn’t a big deal if you’re connecting to a laptop directly, but it locks you out of some tabletop modules like the previously mentioned Analog Four MKII.

A workaround is to use a USB MIDI interface, which allows you to send USB MIDI signals through traditional 5-pin MIDI. However, as any laptop user will tell you, ports are a limited commodity. For reference, this is an example of a connection chain to support legacy gear:

USB MIDI Keyboard -> Computer -> USB MIDI Interface -> 5-Pin MIDI Cable -> Legacy Hardware

While this shows it’s possible to use USB MIDI controllers regardless, it does present added hassle.

MIDI to USB interface

6) Pads: Pads are fun, but they’re not a must. They are essentially better buttons, though, due to their larger size, especially if you’re playing on another main keyboard.

Finger drumming is something many prefer, but I find keyboard-drumming more precise. Your own personal mileage may vary.

7) Pedal Support: Much like digital pianos, it features a pedal jack. However, not all models have this, particularly the portable 25-key models.

Regardless, better safe than sorry, and it’s always better to ensure that you’re getting pedal support, proprietary or otherwise.

Music Production DAWs apps

8) Software Support: Some controllers are designed to integrate well with specific software, and this could push it up a few notches in your own personal lists.

We tested our picks on Ableton Live and Mainstage, but we did our best to avoid software-specific features to select the best general picks.

We won’t discuss the included software in the article. Chances are if you’re looking into MIDI controllers, you already own the related VSTs and DAWs.

If you’re starting out, most MIDI controllers include stripped-down versions of DAWs, like Ableton Live Lite and Bitwig 8-track. These aren’t long-term solutions due to their limitations, but they can help you learn the basics.

Speaking of DAWs, you won’t need to worry about DAW compatibility. While certain MIDI controllers, like the Novation Launchkey series for Ableton Live, have a clearly targeted DAW audience, it doesn’t mean they won’t work with other DAWs.

MIDI Learn is a software protocol that’s all about customizability, and it’s available in all major DAWs. Simply click the parameter you wish to assign and move the corresponding knob, fader, or button.

It’s easy to use and makes MIDI controllers usable regardless of which DAW you’re using.

The preamble out of the way, you now have an idea about how MIDI controllers work, so let’s look at our top picks.

1) Arturia KeyStep – Best Portable MIDI Keyboard (25- to 32-key)

Arturia Keystep Review

US: ( What Retailer to Buy From )
Sweetwater Amazon

Arturia made a name for itself as one of the top developers for software emulations of classic synthesizers. They then moved onto hardware with their highly successful Minibrute synthesizer, praised for its solid build quality and excellent sounds.

Arturia’s focus on expanding its product line was what brought around the KeyStep. This is a portable MIDI controller geared towards laptop-based users who are consistently on the go.

This category is dominated by mini-keys, more likely associated with toys over fully-fledged instruments.

Arturia Keystep unboxing

Most people may see recommendations for the ever-popular Akai MPK Mini, or even the Novation Launchkey Mini, both well-reviewed MIDI controllers.

However, the KeyStep wins simply because of how good it feels. The keys, while small, feel a lot more premium, and have a decent amount of travel and springiness.

When compared to the alternatives, there is no competition. The MPK Mini and Launchkey Mini feel cheap and unresponsive, whereas the KeyStep legitimately feels like a real keyboard.

Arturia Keystep 32-key

25 keys are a downer, but it’s also important to remember that these are meant to fit into laptop bags. Size and weight must be kept at a minimum here.

If you want a point of reference, I’d say the KeyStep feels like a good unweighted arranger keyboard. That’s not much of an endorsement but believe me when I say there isn’t much better at this size.

The KeyStep was also designed with full-on connectivity in mind, and it shows in the number of options on offer.

USB MIDI is the obvious one, but 5-pin MIDI and even CV/Gate voltage signals are provided. If you’re using legacy gear or modular synth modules, the KeyStep has you covered.

Build quality is also best-in-class here. The KeyStep is plastic, but feels sturdy and is well suited for rugged laptop bags. The knobs and buttons feel much better than the competition.

Where it falters is in the lack of controls. The pitch bend and mod wheel exist as touch strips, which I feel is much better than the MPK Mini’s joystick and the Launchkey Mini’s nothing (though the new MK3 includes touch strips as well).

Arturia Keystep live performance

That’s the limit of positives for controls. The onboard knobs are all used for the sequencer and arpeggiator functions (which are robust for such a compact package), and the buttons are for transport controls only.

Pads are also notably absent, though neither the Launchkey nor the MPK Mini’s pads feel especially good.

Is this a deal-breaker? It depends on what you’re looking for. Personally, I’ll take good keys and build quality over all else. The KeyStep is easily the best portable MIDI keyboard out there, and it doubles as a proficient MIDI controller.

While you won’t go wrong with the KeyStep, I would suggest testing out alternatives if given the chance. The Launchkey Mini might be worth it if you’re using Ableton Live as your main DAW.

Pros
  • Best compact mini keys on the market
  • Good build quality
  • 5-pin MIDI and CV/Gate support
Cons
  • Lack of knobs and buttons

Alternatives

We talked briefly about the MPK Mini and the Launchkey Mini above. We don’t consider them viable controllers, but you can always try their bigger counterparts, the Akai MPK225 and Launchkey 25.

These dodge the problem of mini keys, but I still give the KeyStep the edge in that regard. The good controls are even more prominent here though and might just push you over the edge.

You could also consider the Arturia MiniLab, an even more miniaturized variation of the Arturia formula, but it has knobs and pads at the cost of 5-pin MIDI and CV.

This is a purely computer-based solution, but it still feels far superior to the competition.

2) Nektar SE49 – Best Budget MIDI Keyboard (below $200) 

Nektar SE49 review

US: ( What Retailer to Buy From )
Sweetwater Amazon

While the Arturia KeyStep is great, it’s not something I’ll use for playing complex parts like chords or piano pieces. The 25-key limit means I have only 2 octaves to work with, which is extremely limiting.

That’s why we recommend the Nektar SE49. 49 keys aren’t a lot either, but Nektar more than makes up for it with their playability and simple control scheme.

Nektar as a company was founded to make MIDI controllers that closely integrated with DAWs, specifically Reason, giving you the ideal experience of being able to operate without even glancing at your computer screen.

This laser focus lends itself to specific DAW audiences but is not ideal for a general consumer. Thankfully, Nektar excels at good keyboards, and that same level of quality is seen with the SE49.

It’s worth noting that this category is highly contested. The Roland A-49 is a slightly more expensive option that’s a bit older, but it is well praised for offering good value for money.

Nektar SE49 MIDI

The M-Audio Keystation series, on the other hand, lags in terms of playability but features 5-pin MIDI support.

In fact, that’s the first blow against the SE49. You’re operating strictly on USB MIDI here. If you’ve got MIDI modules in mind, you might want to consider the Keystation.

Apart from that, the SE49 is plagued by the absence of more controls. A fader, pitch and mod wheels, and 4 buttons (which double as octave switchers) are all you get. And again, no pads – yikes!

Nektar SE49 front controls

However, the SE49 makes up for this by including one of the best unweighted keyboards I’ve played. Only the semi-weighted keys on the Novation Impulse (which costs 4 times more) beats it.

In my opinion, this beats out other options in this price range by simply feeling the best. I can play piano, synth, and organ on the SE49 without much issue.

Nektar SE49 connectors

The Keystation falters on account of its weak keybed, and while the Roland A-49 feels good with synths, it doesn’t feel as good with glides and glissandos.

The only thing that would have made the SE49’s keys perfect would be aftertouch, but it straight up doesn’t exist with the competitors at this price point, so I won’t hold it against Nektar.

Even the controls, limited as they are, feel high-quality. The pitch bend and mod wheels feel very precise despite their cheap look, which was unexpected.

The biggest pro of the SE49 is its price. This is one of the most affordable 49-key MIDI controllers out there, and it thankfully hits well above its weight class.

Even the Keystation 49 costs more, and I’d argue that it’s a worse deal unless you desperately require 5-pin MIDI. Seriously, go with the SE49. As far as price to performance ratios go, this is tough to beat.

Pros
  • Great keybed for the price
  • Very affordable
  • Decent build quality
Cons
  • USB MIDI only
  • No aftertouch
  • Lack of controls

Alternatives

In terms of alternatives, the Keystation series as well as the Oxygen line (if you need more controls) have variants with more keys, which might make it seem like the obvious choice if more keys are needed.

However, Nektar also makes the Impact GX61, which is cheaper than the Keystation 61 while featuring an upgraded build quality over the SE49.

Alternatively, if you’re willing to spend more, I recommend checking out the M-Audio Code series and the Novation Launchkey series (non-mini versions). These are all well-praised options that justify the extra price, giving you aftertouch, semi-weighted keys, and so on.

3) Arturia KeyLab MKII – Best Controls

Arturia KeyLab 49 MKII review

US: ( What Retailer to Buy From )
Sweetwater Amazon

We’ve been skimping on excess controls so far, which seems counterintuitive to the design of MIDI controllers. However, we stand by the fact that keys are the most important aspect of any keyboard.

Regardless, for people who want a lot of knobs and buttons, the Arturia Keylab is the way to go. We’ve already introduced Arturia, so you know their pedigree as one of the top names in computer music.

Arturia KeyLab 61 MKII studio

The KeyLab series is split into the mainline series (KeyLab 49, 61, and 88 which is weighted) and the Essential series (KeyLab Essential 49 and 61).

The differences primarily regard the layout and the Essential line’s reduced number of controls. We’ll consider the series, but our opinions will be based on the KeyLab 49 MKII, which we believe is a better option.

Arturia KeyLab 61 MKII controls

The KeyLab takes the KeyStep design ethos and cranks it up to eleven. You get the same robust build quality with bonus wooden sides, a full-sized keybed, and actual controls beyond the transport buttons.

The keybed itself feels good and roughly identical regardless of which model you choose. Considering Arturia managed to make good on a mini-sized keyboard, I’m not surprised that their fully-grown brethren excel, too.

The keys here feel great and are a great fit for any playstyle once you’ve gotten used to them.

The KeyLab 88 is the only exception, featuring an ungraded piano-style weighted keyboard. While I did find it good, I think there are better options out there.

Even the FP-30 (which admittedly features Roland’s PHA-4 Standard action) feels better despite a much lower cost.

Arturia KeyLab 61 MKII white

Arturia KeyLab 61 MKII (white version)

Everything here feels physically sound. The pitch and mod wheels are physical and have a light response and quick return time that feels somewhat like the Nord-style keyboards many of us covet.

Pads are also included (4×4 matrix on the mainline, and 4×2 on the Essential). The pads are less Akai MPC-style resistant, and more like the Native Instrument’s Maschine-style responsiveness.

This is a personal preference, but I find myself enjoying these a lot more than those on the Akai MIDI keyboards.

The faders, knobs, and buttons feel like they came off real hardware mixing boards, and there’s even a simple LCD screen to provide visual feedback when necessary.

The magic with the LCD screen is that the KeyLab comes with preset configurations for well-known DAWs and hardware synthesizers.

No matter what DAW you use (apart from FL Studio, which feels like a weird omission considering its popularity), there’s a default setup you can use and modify to taste. Arturia even provides printed labels you can use to change the button descriptors.

Arturia KeyLab KII connectivity

Since you have MIDI and CV/Gate connections, you can also use preset configurations with most hardware synthesizers, modern or otherwise.

Using this with the Prophet 6 available in the store was seamless, and I saw a lot of recognizable names in the menus.

Overall, I’d say the KeyLab is the best in its class. While some might consider the price to be a negative, there are many worse keyboards that cost more, and you really are getting a lot more than you pay for.

Pros
  • Full connectivity options provided
  • Good keys and controls
  • Versatile configuration with provided presets
Cons
  • Slightly higher price

Alternatives

For a higher price, you can get the Novation SL MKIII-series keyboards, designed specifically with Ableton Live in mind, integrating its 8×2 pad matrix and multiple color-LCD screens with the workflow directly.

 

While I love the SL MKIII as an Ableton Live user, it doesn’t integrate as well with other software and hardware. I’ll still note it down here as an excellent choice though.

The AKAI MPK249/261, Novation Launchkey, and the Nektar Impact LX series are MIDI keyboards available at a cheaper price, and they’re solid choices if the KeyLab feels too expensive.

I personally favor the Impact LX over the other two, but Akai is known for making sturdy products that last a long time.

These options aren’t exactly excellent, but they offer a good amount of controls for the price. The KeyLab is slightly ahead when it comes to playability and integration.

4) Novation Impulse – Best Semi-Weighted MIDI Controller

Novation Impulse review

US: ( What Retailer to Buy From )
Sweetwater Amazon

Novation is another veteran MIDI controller. Their earliest controllers focused on providing as much control as possible. In fact, the ‘father of controllerism’ Moldover himself began by heavily modifying one of the earliest Novation SL keyboards to make his dreams of complete control a reality.

Novation Impulse keyboard

Novation is most well-known for its Launchpad line, which featured simple 8×8 pad controllers made for sample triggering, and these were surprisingly successful for performance purposes.

Many now write off Novation as just ‘the Launchpad company,’ but their legacy speaks for itself. They know what people want and they’re good at making things that work well.

We already spoke briefly about the latest MKIII SL iteration, but that’s not the only product to consider.

The Novation Impulse is an old MIDI controller, but the keyboard is one of the best I’ve played, and it even comes close to surpassing the semi-weighted 73-key variation of the Nord Stage 3.

Let’s talk about the keys first. They are semi-weighted and come in 25-61 key variations. The 61-key model is the one we’ll refer to.

Basically, semi-weighted keys feel somewhat like light piano keys, making them a happy medium between weighted and synth-action keys.

I personally prefer them over straight-up unweighted keys because of their versatility. Being able to play both piano and synth parts convincingly without changing your technique is quite useful, as you won’t need to switch between controllers just to get your ideas out.

Novation Impulse keys

The keys here are still the best semi-weighted keys I’ve played, despite being released in 2012, and I still recommend them. Velocity response and aftertouch are good, though aftertouch feels slightly uneven on the black keys.

Either way, keys aren’t the Impulse’s only advantage. There is a good amount of controls here such as pads, faders, and buttons, which unfortunately feel less premium due to their age. The SL does have the edge here, especially in terms of integration.

However, Novation’s built-in Automap software works well enough for most plugins and DAWs, though some of the more recent plugins aren’t supported.

Most of the common ones are still used to this day though, and I didn’t find many failures while using it.

Novation Impulse front controls

As you’ve probably noted throughout this article, controls take a back seat to good keys for us. The Impulse is a great keyboard at a good price, and one might even call it a good ‘impulse’ buy, pun intended.

Pros
  • One of the best semi-weighted keyboards available
  • All the controls you need
Cons
  • Everything apart from the keyboard feels a bit dated

Alternatives

There’s a better option if you’re willing to sacrifice a lot of controls and pay a lot more. Native Instruments is the biggest name in the business, and their plugins and hardware integrate well with each other.

Their new Komplete Kontrol S series includes semi-weighted keyboards courtesy of Fatar.

If that name sounds familiar, it’s because they’re responsible for the keys on all Nord keyboards, as well as the new up and coming company Dexibell.

The 49- and 61-key variants of the Komplete Control (henceforth known as the S49 and S61) are virtual carbon-copies of the Nord Stage 3 73’s semi-weighted keyboard, and I have to say they’re hard to beat.

These keyboards also include a high-resolution OLED display that gives you direct control of NKS supported plugins, something no other MIDI controller can attest.

The only major downsides to this keyboard are a hefty price and a limited number of controls. Even so, the screen + knob combination is efficient and hampered only by a lack of full-fledged support from non-Native Instruments plugins.

5) Kawai VPC1 – Best Weighted Keys

Kawai VPC1 review

US: ( What Retailer to Buy From )
Sweetwater Amazon

Kawai needs no introduction as prolific acoustic and digital piano makers, having been around since 1927.

The Kawai VPC1 was a surprise when released in 2014, but it’s gone on to become a top option for people who want an acoustic piano-style experience that integrates with their software and hardware modules.

For the longest time, people resorted to actual digital pianos for that accurate replication of feel. Options like the Akai MPK88 existed but never compared to the more professional touch of actual digital pianos.

While getting an affordable yet well-reviewed digital piano (such as the excellent FP-30) is a valid option, you need to pay top dollar for wooden keys and responsive sensors. Kawai’s VPC1 felt like the natural answer to that problem.

The VPC1 is the most limited MIDI controller on this list, as there isn’t much to work with in terms of controls. You get a power button, USB MIDI and 5-pin connections, and the full-sized 88-key keyboard.

No faders, no buttons, nothing at all. This might seem blasphemous, but you’d be surprised to find that companies like Akai and M-Audio are attempting to recreate this minimalist product with their own Akai Road 88 and the M-Audio Hammer.

Kawai VPC1 inside key action

Sadly, they don’t come close. The Kawai VPC1 has the best keyboard of the bunch and is worth the price of admission.

If you look up the price, breathe deeply. Over $1,000 seems like a lot until you realize you’re getting the RM3II wooden key action.

These keys are far from plastic blocks and compare to the Grand Feel key actions featured on Kawai’s flagship console-style digital pianos (which cost many times more).

Kawai RM3 Grand II key action

With the RM3II action, you get a simulated acoustic feel with graded hammers, counterweights on keys, synthetic ivory-textured surfaces, and triple sensor detection for repetitive key presses.

Each key is a solid piece of wood of similar length to a real piano, which combined with a seesaw action mechanism, offers an incredible amount of realism.

A triple pedal setup also comes with the controller, providing soft, sostenuto, and damper pedaling in one package. As with Kawai’s digital pianos, these feel realistic and support half-damper functionality.

You even get to customize your own velocity curves using the VPC editor software.

This is the best piano-style weighted key action you can get in a MIDI controller. The competition (especially the Akai Road) comes close, but it’s not worth saving if you want the closest to the real deal.

More so than anywhere else, you’ll need to pair this with a good software piano. Again, I recommend you check out our breakdown of all our top piano VST plugins to find one that works best for you.

Pros
  • Best fully weighted key action on a non-digital piano
  • Excellent build quality
  • Piano-style design
Cons
  • Price
  • Relatively heavy
  • No controls

Alternatives

While the Akai Road 88 seems enticing due to costing 3/4 of the price, I’d say the M-Audio Hammer or the Studiologic SL88 Grand is a better value-for-money option.

The latter comes with Fatar’s premium TP/40 Wood action, which feels superior to the SL88 Studio with a lighter and more basic action, the TP/100LR.

The actions still feel worse than Kawai’s RM3II, but they have a few bonuses that justify the downgrade.

It also helps that they cost less than half the price of the Kawai VPC1.

6) Roli Seaboard – Best Innovation

Roli Seaboard Rise 25 review

US: ( What Retailer to Buy From )
Sweetwater Amazon
UK & Europe:
Amazon UK Thomann

If there’s one takeaway from this whole article, it’s that MIDI controllers are all about giving the user control.

Knobs, buttons, and faders seem archaic, but they’re an easy method for interacting with sound parameters to add expressivity.

However, those feel more like an engineer’s tool, as opposed to that of a musician. Roli is a company formed to tackle that issue head-on. Their products, from the Roli Lightpad Block to the Roli Seaboard, don’t have knobs or buttons.

Instead, they use the simple concept of aftertouch and add extra dimensions to enhance performance capabilities.

Imagine controlling a synthesizer’s filter cutoff point by moving your finger up and down the keys. Perhaps even controlling pitch bend by moving your fingers horizontally!

This is all possible with the Seaboard, and it’s something quite unique. If you’ve ever used Korg’s famous Kaoss pads, this feels like that, but in keyboard form.

Touch is the name of the game here, and Roli even designed their own software plugins to take full advantage of their keyboard. These come with every Seaboard model you can buy, and while they’re complicated, the sounds are worth the effort.

The problem here is the price. The cheapest Seaboard Block is many times the price of other 25-key controllers, and the Seaboard Rise 49-key variant costs nearly as much as the Kawai VPC1! That’s no small investment.

However, this is innovation the way we like it. It’s hard to say how things will change in the coming years, but we’re looking forward to more innovative products like the Seaboard from other companies.


Honorable Mentions

The Roli Seaboard requires you to significantly alter your playstyle, so what if you like your current keyboard?

Well, a lot of other products act as accessories to enhance performance, rather than replace your current rig. These include the ring-based MIDI controller from Enhancia that reacts to movement dynamically, sending CC changes as you move your hands.

On paper, this seems less cool than the Seaboard, but it might be worth looking into if you’re hitting a creative wall in your performances and want to spice things up.

Sustain Pedals

Sustain pedals are omitted on all but the Kawai VPC1, so you’ll need to shell out a bit more cash to unlock full functionality. Something worth considering when purchasing pedals for MIDI controllers is whether you require half-pedaling.

Pedals with half-damper support cost a bit more but are well worth the extra price to enhance realism on supporting plugins like Keyscape.

Our favorite damper pedal that supports half-pedaling (and our favorite sustain pedal in general) is Korg’s DS-1H. This small pedal is built like a tank and will last you many years even if you chuck it around.

It’s also not a square block-style pedal, which is something we prefer. The DS-1H feels good, with a decent amount of resistance so you can rest atop it, but not so much that you’ll struggle to push downwards.

If you decide that half-pedaling is unnecessary, your options open greatly. We recommend the Nektar NP-2 for its cheap price and good build quality. The M-Audio SP-2 is a good alternative as well.

Final Words

MIDI controllers are interesting if you’re willing to dive deep, and I hope we’ve given you an idea of what to look for. If you’ve gotten this far, I want to strongly recommend you consider your main purposes.

We’ve tried our best to provide general recommendations that work well regardless of your DAW or hardware preferences, but certain other options might be preferable because of their close integration. The Komplete Kontrol and Novation SL come to mind.

While we stand by our stance that keys are the most important aspect, there are other factors to consider.

If you’re already a stage performer who loves your Roland RD-2000, you don’t need a fully-fledged MIDI controller to add to your control capabilities.

You can easily get away with a cheap Akai LPD8 for some buttons and knobs, or even a cheap Korg nanoKONTROL for faders. Both suggestions can even fit into your gig bag without adding much weight.

You’re not limited to single products when it comes to controllers, and as we said early on, the sky is the limit. As always, we recommend going into stores to test out your purchases beforehand whenever possible. A good feel is something we always look for and being subjective means that what we like might not be your personal favorite.

Regardless, we hope you’ve enjoyed this breakdown of MIDI controllers. If you want to know more about piano VSTs and plugins, we invite you to review our previous coverage for a pro’s thoughts on the matter.


You might also like:

The Ultimate Guide to Buying a Digital Piano

Digital Piano Buying Guide

Best DAWs Today: How to Choose Your First DAW?

Best DAWs

Best Studio Monitors: The Ultimate Buying Guide

Best Studio Monitors

Build a Home Recording Studio With Me: Step-by-Step Guide

Build a Home Recording Studio

11 Comments

  1. Avatar Adam Plesník January 24, 2020
    • Lucas Welter Lucas Welter February 1, 2020
  2. Avatar Lee May 27, 2020
    • Lucas Welter Lucas Welter June 25, 2020
  3. Avatar Addi June 24, 2020
    • Lucas Welter Lucas Welter July 4, 2020
  4. Avatar Tom July 21, 2020
    • Avatar Tom July 22, 2020
      • Lucas Welter Lucas Welter August 14, 2020
  5. Avatar Gernot August 5, 2020
    • Lucas Welter Lucas Welter August 14, 2020

Leave a Reply

shares